Be A Freedom Fighter · Bill Library

HR 10737 — Establishing Gold Standard Science Act

Freedom score: -3 (scale −10 to +10)

Sponsor: Rep. Franklin, Scott [R-FL-18] · Latest action: Referred to the House Committee on Science, Space, and Technology. (2026-10-05)

Full text on GovInfo (introduced version) · Congress.gov · ← Bill Library index

Findings — 10 highlighted provisions

Each item below is one provision documented in the findings file. The same provision is highlighted in the full text underneath, with its section citation and criterion. Everything else on this page is plain, unreviewed bill text.

  1. Sec. 2(b), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(h)(2)–(3) · Individual Rights — Bans federally registered lobbyists from EPA Science Advisory Board appointment and from certain panels involving their lobbying or direct financial interests; disqualifies appointed members from participation in work that evaluates their own research, financial interests, affiliated entities, or those of immediate family. The appointment/participation restrictions are enforced through exclusion and recusal; no new civil or criminal fine is stated See in text ↓
  2. Sec. 2(c), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(i)(2)(B), (3)–(4) · Individual Rights — Requires appointees to disclose prior professional activities, public statements, expert testimony and representation relevant to advisory work, and update disclosures annually and immediately as specified. This is compelled occupational speech for voluntary appointees; the statutory text states no separate fine See in text ↓
  3. Sec. 2(d)(1)–(3), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(c)(2), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(d)(2), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(j), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(k) · Individual Rights — Requires EPA Board advice/comments to state reliance on the executive-order-defined Gold Standard Science and weight of evidence; directs the Administrator and chair to seek open exchange and differing viewpoints; creates member allegation, Administrator investigation and mandatory removal/permanent ineligibility upon an affirmative scientific-misconduct determination. No express hearing or appeal is created See in text ↓
  4. Sec. 2(b), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(h)(4) · Privacy and Due Process — Requires written recusal agreements identifying excluded matters, with prompt public posting by the EPA Administrator; this publishes conflict details about serving appointees See in text ↓
  5. Sec. 2(c), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(i)(1)–(6) · Privacy and Due Process — Requires original, annual, and immediate written public-disclosure reporting of five-year financial interests, professional work, public statements, relevant federal grants and National Academies participation; EPA annual reports and summaries go to Congress. Expressly provides that past research, grants and professional experience do not by themselves disqualify a member; the scope of public availability of each individual report versus the annual summary is not fully specified See in text ↓
  6. Sec. 2(d)(3), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(k)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Allegations prompt mandatory EPA investigation and decision; a positive finding mandates removal and bars later appointment, without a specifically prescribed notice, hearing or evidentiary standard See in text ↓
  7. Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions See in text ↓
  8. Sec. 2(b)–(c) · Government Power — Imposes new EPA nomination/recusal, disclosure administration, public-release, and annual congressional reporting obligations; EPA Administrator standardizes submissions See in text ↓
  9. Sec. 2(d)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Imposes Board scientific-evidence standards and delegates scientific-misconduct determinations to EPA Administrator, with compulsory removal and future appointment bar See in text ↓
  10. Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated See in text ↓

Full text (introduced version)

44 of 45 text blocks highlighted. Source: GovInfo, fetched cached.

[Congressional Bills 119th Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] [H.R. 10737 Introduced in House (IH)] <DOC> 119th CONGRESS 2d Session H. R. 10737 To amend the Environmental Research, Development, and Demonstration Authorization Act of 1978 to promote transparency in science, and for other purposes. _______________________________________________________________________ IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES October 5, 2026 Mr. Scott Franklin of Florida (for himself, Mr. Obernolte, Mr. Haridopolos, Mr. Self, Mr. Weber of Texas, Mr. McCormick, Mr. Webster of Florida, Mr. Fleischmann, Mr. Ellzey, Mr. Van Epps, Mr. Harrigan, Mr. Baird, and Mr. Issa) introduced the following bill; which was referred to the Committee on Science, Space, and Technology _______________________________________________________________________ A BILL To amend the Environmental Research, Development, and Demonstration Authorization Act of 1978 to promote transparency in science, and for other purposes. Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled,

SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.

This Act may be cited as the ``Establishing Gold Standard Science Act''.

SEC. 2. PROMOTING TRANSPARENCY IN SCIENCE.

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

(a) Definitions.--The Environmental Research, Development, and Demonstration Authorization Act of 1978 (Public Law 95-155; 91 Stat. 1257) is amended by inserting before section 2 the following new section: ``SECTION 1A. DEFINITIONS. ``In this Act, the terms `Gold Standard Science', `scientific information', `scientific misconduct', and `weight of scientific evidence' have the meanings given such terms in Executive Order 14303 (90 Fed. Reg. 22601), signed on May 23, 2025, and entitled `Restoring Gold Standard Science'.''.

Sec. 2(b), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(h)(2)–(3) · Individual Rights — Bans federally registered lobbyists from EPA Science Advisory Board appointment and from certain panels involving their lobbying or direct financial interests; disqualifies appointed members from participation in work that evaluates their own research, financial interests, affiliated entities, or those of immediate family. The appointment/participation restrictions are enforced through exclusion and recusal; no new civil or criminal fine is stated

Sec. 2(b), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(h)(4) · Privacy and Due Process — Requires written recusal agreements identifying excluded matters, with prompt public posting by the EPA Administrator; this publishes conflict details about serving appointees

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(b)–(c) · Government Power — Imposes new EPA nomination/recusal, disclosure administration, public-release, and annual congressional reporting obligations; EPA Administrator standardizes submissions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

(b) Public Participation and Transparency.--Subsection (h) of section 8 of the Environmental Research, Development, and Demonstration Authorization Act of 1978 (42 U.S.C. 4365) is amended--

Sec. 2(b), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(h)(2)–(3) · Individual Rights — Bans federally registered lobbyists from EPA Science Advisory Board appointment and from certain panels involving their lobbying or direct financial interests; disqualifies appointed members from participation in work that evaluates their own research, financial interests, affiliated entities, or those of immediate family. The appointment/participation restrictions are enforced through exclusion and recusal; no new civil or criminal fine is stated

Sec. 2(b), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(h)(4) · Privacy and Due Process — Requires written recusal agreements identifying excluded matters, with prompt public posting by the EPA Administrator; this publishes conflict details about serving appointees

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(b)–(c) · Government Power — Imposes new EPA nomination/recusal, disclosure administration, public-release, and annual congressional reporting obligations; EPA Administrator standardizes submissions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

(1) by striking ``The Board shall make'' and inserting ``(1) The Board shall make''; and

Sec. 2(b), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(h)(2)–(3) · Individual Rights — Bans federally registered lobbyists from EPA Science Advisory Board appointment and from certain panels involving their lobbying or direct financial interests; disqualifies appointed members from participation in work that evaluates their own research, financial interests, affiliated entities, or those of immediate family. The appointment/participation restrictions are enforced through exclusion and recusal; no new civil or criminal fine is stated

Sec. 2(b), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(h)(4) · Privacy and Due Process — Requires written recusal agreements identifying excluded matters, with prompt public posting by the EPA Administrator; this publishes conflict details about serving appointees

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(b)–(c) · Government Power — Imposes new EPA nomination/recusal, disclosure administration, public-release, and annual congressional reporting obligations; EPA Administrator standardizes submissions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

(2) by adding at the end the following new paragraphs:

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(2) No federally registered lobbyist may be appointed to any of the following:

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(A) The Board.

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(B) A committee or investigative panel under subsection (e) regarding any of the following matters: ``(i) A matter for which such lobbyist is so registered. ``(ii) A matter in which such lobbyist has a direct financial interest.

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(3) No individual appointed to the Board or a committee or investigative panel under subsection (e) may participate in an advisory activity--

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(A) that directly involves the review or evaluation of the work of such individual;

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(B) in which such individual has a direct affiliation with, or represents an entity that has a direct financial interest in, an outcome of the Board's advisory activity on the matter at issue, or that directly involves the review or evaluation of such interest or activity, as the case may be; or

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(C) in which such individual's spouse, partner, child, parent, or other immediate family member has a direct affiliation with, or represents an entity that has a direct financial interest in, an outcome of the Board's advisory activity on the matter at issue, or that directly involves the review or evaluation of such interest or activity, as the case may be.

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(4) An individual described in paragraph (3) who is a member of the Board or appointed to a committee or investigative panel under subsection (e) on, before, or after the date of the enactment of this paragraph shall promptly submit to the Administrator a formal recusal agreement that includes information relating to an identification of each matter of the Board or such committee or investigative panel, as the case may be, from which such individual is so recused, and the Administrator shall promptly make such recusal agreement publicly available.''.

Sec. 2(c), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(i)(2)(B), (3)–(4) · Individual Rights — Requires appointees to disclose prior professional activities, public statements, expert testimony and representation relevant to advisory work, and update disclosures annually and immediately as specified. This is compelled occupational speech for voluntary appointees; the statutory text states no separate fine

Sec. 2(c), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(i)(1)–(6) · Privacy and Due Process — Requires original, annual, and immediate written public-disclosure reporting of five-year financial interests, professional work, public statements, relevant federal grants and National Academies participation; EPA annual reports and summaries go to Congress. Expressly provides that past research, grants and professional experience do not by themselves disqualify a member; the scope of public availability of each individual report versus the annual summary is not fully specified

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(b)–(c) · Government Power — Imposes new EPA nomination/recusal, disclosure administration, public-release, and annual congressional reporting obligations; EPA Administrator standardizes submissions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

(c) Annual Reports.--Subsection (i) of section 8 of the Environmental Research, Development, and Demonstration Authorization Act of 1978 (42 U.S.C. 4365) is amended--

Sec. 2(c), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(i)(2)(B), (3)–(4) · Individual Rights — Requires appointees to disclose prior professional activities, public statements, expert testimony and representation relevant to advisory work, and update disclosures annually and immediately as specified. This is compelled occupational speech for voluntary appointees; the statutory text states no separate fine

Sec. 2(c), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(i)(1)–(6) · Privacy and Due Process — Requires original, annual, and immediate written public-disclosure reporting of five-year financial interests, professional work, public statements, relevant federal grants and National Academies participation; EPA annual reports and summaries go to Congress. Expressly provides that past research, grants and professional experience do not by themselves disqualify a member; the scope of public availability of each individual report versus the annual summary is not fully specified

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(b)–(c) · Government Power — Imposes new EPA nomination/recusal, disclosure administration, public-release, and annual congressional reporting obligations; EPA Administrator standardizes submissions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

(1) in the heading, by striking ``Report'' and inserting ``Reports'';

Sec. 2(c), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(i)(2)(B), (3)–(4) · Individual Rights — Requires appointees to disclose prior professional activities, public statements, expert testimony and representation relevant to advisory work, and update disclosures annually and immediately as specified. This is compelled occupational speech for voluntary appointees; the statutory text states no separate fine

Sec. 2(c), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(i)(1)–(6) · Privacy and Due Process — Requires original, annual, and immediate written public-disclosure reporting of five-year financial interests, professional work, public statements, relevant federal grants and National Academies participation; EPA annual reports and summaries go to Congress. Expressly provides that past research, grants and professional experience do not by themselves disqualify a member; the scope of public availability of each individual report versus the annual summary is not fully specified

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(b)–(c) · Government Power — Imposes new EPA nomination/recusal, disclosure administration, public-release, and annual congressional reporting obligations; EPA Administrator standardizes submissions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

(2) by striking ``The Administrator shall annually report'' and inserting ``(1) The Administrator shall annually report'';

Sec. 2(c), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(i)(2)(B), (3)–(4) · Individual Rights — Requires appointees to disclose prior professional activities, public statements, expert testimony and representation relevant to advisory work, and update disclosures annually and immediately as specified. This is compelled occupational speech for voluntary appointees; the statutory text states no separate fine

Sec. 2(c), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(i)(1)–(6) · Privacy and Due Process — Requires original, annual, and immediate written public-disclosure reporting of five-year financial interests, professional work, public statements, relevant federal grants and National Academies participation; EPA annual reports and summaries go to Congress. Expressly provides that past research, grants and professional experience do not by themselves disqualify a member; the scope of public availability of each individual report versus the annual summary is not fully specified

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(b)–(c) · Government Power — Imposes new EPA nomination/recusal, disclosure administration, public-release, and annual congressional reporting obligations; EPA Administrator standardizes submissions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

(3) in paragraph (1), as so designated, by adding at the end the following new sentence: ``The Administrator shall include in each such report any immediate disclosures under paragraph (4), and make each such report publicly available.''; and

Sec. 2(c), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(i)(2)(B), (3)–(4) · Individual Rights — Requires appointees to disclose prior professional activities, public statements, expert testimony and representation relevant to advisory work, and update disclosures annually and immediately as specified. This is compelled occupational speech for voluntary appointees; the statutory text states no separate fine

Sec. 2(c), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(i)(1)–(6) · Privacy and Due Process — Requires original, annual, and immediate written public-disclosure reporting of five-year financial interests, professional work, public statements, relevant federal grants and National Academies participation; EPA annual reports and summaries go to Congress. Expressly provides that past research, grants and professional experience do not by themselves disqualify a member; the scope of public availability of each individual report versus the annual summary is not fully specified

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(b)–(c) · Government Power — Imposes new EPA nomination/recusal, disclosure administration, public-release, and annual congressional reporting obligations; EPA Administrator standardizes submissions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

(4) by adding at the end the following new paragraphs:

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(2) Upon being appointed, each member of the Board, and each appointee to a committee or investigative panel under subsection (e), shall submit to the Administrator a written report, standardized by the Administrator, disclosing the following with respect to such member or appointee, as the case may be:

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(A) All financial relationships and interests, including grants, contracts, cooperative agreements, or other financial assistance, that satisfy any of the following requirements: ``(i) Are with a public or private entity relevant to the Board's advisory activity for the five-year period prior to the date of such appointment. ``(ii) Might pose a conflict of interest with respect to the Board's advisory activity.

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(B) All professional activities and public statements that are relevant to the Board's advisory activity for the five-year period prior to the date of such appointment, including all representational work, expert testimony, and contract work, and an identification of each party for which such work or testimony, as the case may be, was undertaken or provided.

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(C) Any participation, including any direct relationships or interests, in activities paid for by grants or funds administered by the Environmental Protection Agency, the Department of Agriculture, the Department of Energy, the Department of Commerce, the Department of Transportation, or other relevant agencies, with respect to matters that are relevant to the Board's advisory activity for the five-year period prior to the date of such appointment.

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(D) Any participation in the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine or an entity thereof, including any direct relationships or interests, or activities, paid for by grants or funds administered by the National Academies or such entity thereof.

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(3) Each member of the Board, and each appointee to a committee or investigative panel under subsection (e), shall annually submit to the Administrator a written report, standardized by the Administrator, disclosing any updates to the matters described in paragraph (2), including any immediate updates under paragraph (4).

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(4) Notwithstanding the annual updates under paragraph (3), each member of the Board, and each appointee to a committee or investigative panel under subsection (e), shall immediately submit to the Administrator a written report, standardized by the Administrator, disclosing any financial relationships or interests, including grants, contracts, cooperative agreements, or other financial assistance, entered into with or received from any public or private entity since the date of the submission of such an annual update that are relevant to the Board's advisory activity.

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(5) The Administrator shall annually submit to the Committee on Science, Space, and Technology of the House of Representatives and the Committee on Environment and Public Works of the Senate a report on the composition and activities of each committee or investigative panel under subsection (e), including a summary of the information required under paragraphs (2) through (4).

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(6) A disclosure pursuant to paragraph (2), a professional activity or public statement referred to in subparagraph (B) of such paragraph, participation described in subparagraph (C) or (D) of such paragraph, professional expertise, prior research or publication, or prior service with respect to an entity that has a direct financial interest in an outcome of the Board's advisory activity does not, in itself, pose a conflict of interest with respect to the Board's advisory activity or disqualify a member of the Board from such membership or an appointee to a committee or investigative panel under subsection (e) from such appointment.''.

Sec. 2(d)(1)–(3), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(c)(2), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(d)(2), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(j), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(k) · Individual Rights — Requires EPA Board advice/comments to state reliance on the executive-order-defined Gold Standard Science and weight of evidence; directs the Administrator and chair to seek open exchange and differing viewpoints; creates member allegation, Administrator investigation and mandatory removal/permanent ineligibility upon an affirmative scientific-misconduct determination. No express hearing or appeal is created

Sec. 2(d)(3), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(k)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Allegations prompt mandatory EPA investigation and decision; a positive finding mandates removal and bars later appointment, without a specifically prescribed notice, hearing or evidentiary standard

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(d)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Imposes Board scientific-evidence standards and delegates scientific-misconduct determinations to EPA Administrator, with compulsory removal and future appointment bar

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

(d) Advice, Comments, and Conduct.--Section 8 of the Environmental Research, Development, and Demonstration Authorization Act of 1978 (42 U.S.C. 4365) is amended--

Sec. 2(d)(1)–(3), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(c)(2), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(d)(2), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(j), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(k) · Individual Rights — Requires EPA Board advice/comments to state reliance on the executive-order-defined Gold Standard Science and weight of evidence; directs the Administrator and chair to seek open exchange and differing viewpoints; creates member allegation, Administrator investigation and mandatory removal/permanent ineligibility upon an affirmative scientific-misconduct determination. No express hearing or appeal is created

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(d)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Imposes Board scientific-evidence standards and delegates scientific-misconduct determinations to EPA Administrator, with compulsory removal and future appointment bar

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

(1) in subsection (c)(2), by adding at the end the following new sentence: ``Such advice and comments shall include a statement that indicates the Board based such advice and comments on Gold Standard Science and the weight of scientific evidence.'';

Sec. 2(d)(1)–(3), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(c)(2), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(d)(2), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(j), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(k) · Individual Rights — Requires EPA Board advice/comments to state reliance on the executive-order-defined Gold Standard Science and weight of evidence; directs the Administrator and chair to seek open exchange and differing viewpoints; creates member allegation, Administrator investigation and mandatory removal/permanent ineligibility upon an affirmative scientific-misconduct determination. No express hearing or appeal is created

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(d)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Imposes Board scientific-evidence standards and delegates scientific-misconduct determinations to EPA Administrator, with compulsory removal and future appointment bar

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

(2) in subsection (d)-- (A) by striking ``avail'' and inserting ``carry out the following:

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(1) Avail''; and (B) by adding at the end the following new paragraph:

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(2) Base such advice and comments on Gold Standard Science and the weight of scientific evidence.''; and

Sec. 2(d)(1)–(3), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(c)(2), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(d)(2), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(j), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(k) · Individual Rights — Requires EPA Board advice/comments to state reliance on the executive-order-defined Gold Standard Science and weight of evidence; directs the Administrator and chair to seek open exchange and differing viewpoints; creates member allegation, Administrator investigation and mandatory removal/permanent ineligibility upon an affirmative scientific-misconduct determination. No express hearing or appeal is created

Sec. 2(d)(3), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(k)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Allegations prompt mandatory EPA investigation and decision; a positive finding mandates removal and bars later appointment, without a specifically prescribed notice, hearing or evidentiary standard

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(d)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Imposes Board scientific-evidence standards and delegates scientific-misconduct determinations to EPA Administrator, with compulsory removal and future appointment bar

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

(3) by adding at the end the following new subsections:

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(j) Ideas and Viewpoints.--In carrying out this section, the Administrator and the Chairperson of the Board shall seek to ensure the following:

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(1) The open exchange of ideas.

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(2) The consideration of different and dissenting viewpoints across disparate disciplines and in the same discipline.

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(3) A balanced range of scientific expertise, technical perspectives, and viewpoints regarding the matter at issue.

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(k) Scientific Misconduct.--

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(1) Allegation.--A member of the Board, or an appointee to a committee or investigative panel under subsection (e), may allege to the Administrator that another such member or appointee, as the case may be, has committed scientific misconduct with respect to the Board or such committee or investigative panel, as the case may be.

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(2) Investigation and determination.--Upon receipt of an allegation of scientific misconduct under paragraph (1), the Administrator shall investigate such allegation and determine whether such alleged misconduct was committed.

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(3) Removal.--If the Administrator makes a determination in the affirmative under paragraph (2), the following shall apply: ``(A) The Chairperson shall remove the member of the Board, or the appointee to a committee or investigative panel under subsection (e), with respect to whom such determination applies. ``(B) Such removed member or appointee, as the case may be, may not after the date of such removal be appointed to the Board or such committee or investigative panel, as the case may be.''.

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

(e) Scientific Integrity Training Program.--The Environmental Research, Development, and Demonstration Authorization Act of 1978 is amended by inserting after section 6 (42 U.S.C. 4363 note) the following new section: ``SEC. 6A. SCIENTIFIC INTEGRITY TRAINING PROGRAM. ``Not later than 180 days after the date of the enactment of this section, the Administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency shall establish a scientific integrity training program to inform each officer or employee of the Agency of the following:

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(1) The requirements of such officer or employee, as the case may be, with respect to the following: ``(A) Scientific research. ``(B) The publication of such research and scientific information.

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(2) Scientific misconduct.

Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions

Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated

``(3) Gold Standard Science and the weight of scientific evidence.''. <all>

Findings source: bill-scores-v2-batch49-findings-2026-11-15.md. Highlights come only from that file; no finding, score, or provision was invented for this page.

What you can do

Contact your U.S. Representative and Senators about this bill.

Find your Representative Contact your Senators

Spot an error on this page? Report it.