Be A Freedom Fighter · Bill Library
HR 10641 — Employee and Retiree Access to Justice Act
Freedom score: -1 (scale −10 to +10)
- Individual rights: 0
- Property rights: 0
- Economic freedom: -2
- Privacy & due process: +2
- Government power: -1
Sponsor: · Latest action: ()
Full text on GovInfo (introduced version) · Congress.gov · ← Bill Library index
Findings — 10 highlighted provisions
Each item below is one provision documented in the findings file. The same provision is highlighted in the full text underneath, with its section citation and criterion. Everything else on this page is plain, unreviewed bill text.
- Sec. 2(a), new ERISA §502(n)(1)(A)–(D) · Individual Rights — Retirement plan participants/beneficiaries regain access to courts/class or representative legal claims otherwise foreclosed by specified pre-dispute or coerced post-dispute agreements; this is primarily contractual/procedural, not protection of general speech or personal association See in text ↓
- Sec. 2(a), new ERISA §502(n)(1)(A)–(B) · Economic Freedom — Renders mandatory pre-dispute arbitration unenforceable for participant/beneficiary ERISA claims; post-dispute arbitration valid only if noncoerced, plain-language paper notice, at least 45-day waiting period, and affirmative written consent See in text ↓
- Sec. 2(a), new §502(n)(1)(C)–(E) · Economic Freedom — Forbids pre-dispute and inadequately agreed post-dispute class/representative action waivers; for nonmultiemployer plans invalidates clauses providing discretionary interpretation or a judicial review standard other than de novo See in text ↓
- Sec. 2(a), new §502(n)(2)–(3) · Economic Freedom — Defines covered agreements broadly to include separate plan benefit contracts, exempts bona fide collective bargaining products from arbitration-provision definitions, assigns arbitration-enforceability questions to courts (not arbitrators) and determines dispute accrual using claimant actual knowledge See in text ↓
- Sec. 3, new ERISA §402(d)(1)–(2) · Economic Freedom — Prohibits plans, sponsors, employers and plan administrators from requiring/entering the invalid clauses. Market effect is mandatory restriction on private agreements, even where parties might prefer arbitration See in text ↓
- Sec. 2(a), new §502(n)(1)(B), (C)–(E), (3) · Privacy and Due Process — Adds contractual consent/notice waiting protection, preserves class-claim access, prohibits unilateral arbitration gatekeeping and requires de novo judicial review for covered nonmultiemployer plan benefit determinations See in text ↓
- Sec. 4(a)–(b) · Privacy and Due Process — Applies to claims arising/accruing after enactment even if plan document predates; delayed document-update violation until after first plan year beginning at least one year after enactment where administrator acts consistently with amendments See in text ↓
- Sec. 2(b) · Government Power — Secretary of Labor may promulgate rules for notices and statutory implementation; no special new criminal penalty See in text ↓
- Sec. 3 · Government Power — Federal law overrides private arbitration and waiver agreements; existing ERISA causes and court enforcement govern violations See in text ↓
- Sec. 4 · Government Power — Prospective disputes governed immediately; limited plan-document transition period See in text ↓
Full text (introduced version)
11 of 23 text blocks highlighted. Source: GovInfo, fetched cached.
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
SEC. 2. UNENFORCEABLE ARBITRATION CLAUSES, CLASS ACTION WAIVERS, REPRESENTATION WAIVERS, AND DISCRETIONARY CLAUSES.
Sec. 2(a), new ERISA §502(n)(1)(A)–(D) · Individual Rights — Retirement plan participants/beneficiaries regain access to courts/class or representative legal claims otherwise foreclosed by specified pre-dispute or coerced post-dispute agreements; this is primarily contractual/procedural, not protection of general speech or personal association
Sec. 2(a), new ERISA §502(n)(1)(A)–(B) · Economic Freedom — Renders mandatory pre-dispute arbitration unenforceable for participant/beneficiary ERISA claims; post-dispute arbitration valid only if noncoerced, plain-language paper notice, at least 45-day waiting period, and affirmative written consent
Sec. 2(a), new §502(n)(1)(C)–(E) · Economic Freedom — Forbids pre-dispute and inadequately agreed post-dispute class/representative action waivers; for nonmultiemployer plans invalidates clauses providing discretionary interpretation or a judicial review standard other than de novo
Sec. 2(a), new §502(n)(2)–(3) · Economic Freedom — Defines covered agreements broadly to include separate plan benefit contracts, exempts bona fide collective bargaining products from arbitration-provision definitions, assigns arbitration-enforceability questions to courts (not arbitrators) and determines dispute accrual using claimant actual knowledge
Sec. 2(a), new §502(n)(1)(B), (C)–(E), (3) · Privacy and Due Process — Adds contractual consent/notice waiting protection, preserves class-claim access, prohibits unilateral arbitration gatekeeping and requires de novo judicial review for covered nonmultiemployer plan benefit determinations
Sec. 2(b) · Government Power — Secretary of Labor may promulgate rules for notices and statutory implementation; no special new criminal penalty
SEC. 3. PROHIBITION ON MANDATORY ARBITRATION CLAUSES, CLASS ACTION WAIVERS, REPRESENTATION WAIVERS, AND DISCRETIONARY CLAUSES.
Sec. 3, new ERISA §402(d)(1)–(2) · Economic Freedom — Prohibits plans, sponsors, employers and plan administrators from requiring/entering the invalid clauses. Market effect is mandatory restriction on private agreements, even where parties might prefer arbitration
Sec. 3 · Government Power — Federal law overrides private arbitration and waiver agreements; existing ERISA causes and court enforcement govern violations
Sec. 3, new ERISA §402(d)(1)–(2) · Economic Freedom — Prohibits plans, sponsors, employers and plan administrators from requiring/entering the invalid clauses. Market effect is mandatory restriction on private agreements, even where parties might prefer arbitration
Sec. 3 · Government Power — Federal law overrides private arbitration and waiver agreements; existing ERISA causes and court enforcement govern violations
Sec. 3, new ERISA §402(d)(1)–(2) · Economic Freedom — Prohibits plans, sponsors, employers and plan administrators from requiring/entering the invalid clauses. Market effect is mandatory restriction on private agreements, even where parties might prefer arbitration
Sec. 3 · Government Power — Federal law overrides private arbitration and waiver agreements; existing ERISA causes and court enforcement govern violations
Sec. 3, new ERISA §402(d)(1)–(2) · Economic Freedom — Prohibits plans, sponsors, employers and plan administrators from requiring/entering the invalid clauses. Market effect is mandatory restriction on private agreements, even where parties might prefer arbitration
Sec. 3 · Government Power — Federal law overrides private arbitration and waiver agreements; existing ERISA causes and court enforcement govern violations
Sec. 3, new ERISA §402(d)(1)–(2) · Economic Freedom — Prohibits plans, sponsors, employers and plan administrators from requiring/entering the invalid clauses. Market effect is mandatory restriction on private agreements, even where parties might prefer arbitration
Sec. 3 · Government Power — Federal law overrides private arbitration and waiver agreements; existing ERISA causes and court enforcement govern violations
Sec. 3, new ERISA §402(d)(1)–(2) · Economic Freedom — Prohibits plans, sponsors, employers and plan administrators from requiring/entering the invalid clauses. Market effect is mandatory restriction on private agreements, even where parties might prefer arbitration
Sec. 3 · Government Power — Federal law overrides private arbitration and waiver agreements; existing ERISA causes and court enforcement govern violations
Sec. 3, new ERISA §402(d)(1)–(2) · Economic Freedom — Prohibits plans, sponsors, employers and plan administrators from requiring/entering the invalid clauses. Market effect is mandatory restriction on private agreements, even where parties might prefer arbitration
Sec. 3 · Government Power — Federal law overrides private arbitration and waiver agreements; existing ERISA causes and court enforcement govern violations
SEC. 4. EFFECTIVE DATE.
Sec. 4(a)–(b) · Privacy and Due Process — Applies to claims arising/accruing after enactment even if plan document predates; delayed document-update violation until after first plan year beginning at least one year after enactment where administrator acts consistently with amendments
Sec. 4 · Government Power — Prospective disputes governed immediately; limited plan-document transition period
Sec. 4(a)–(b) · Privacy and Due Process — Applies to claims arising/accruing after enactment even if plan document predates; delayed document-update violation until after first plan year beginning at least one year after enactment where administrator acts consistently with amendments
Sec. 4 · Government Power — Prospective disputes governed immediately; limited plan-document transition period
Findings source: bill-scores-v2-batch51-findings-2026-11-15.md. Highlights come only from that file; no finding, score, or provision was invented for this page.
What you can do
Contact your U.S. Representative and Senators about this bill.
Find your Representative Contact your Senators
Spot an error on this page? Report it.